« Hope and Fear | Main | The Kabbalists are coming »

August 12, 2009

Comments

RJM

Does this mean Drazin rejects Onkelos as the author completely, or that he believes the Targum went through a process of editing over several centuries?

Do you have an issue with the theological premises of the work or are you merely identifying them?

david g.

I wrote about Drazin's book on Rambam. I do not know about his work on Onkelkos, but I would be very careful as he has no understanding of rambam's thought. He is far from a rationalist, more in the realm of an ignoramus when it comes to machshava. See my blog labels Drazin.

Lion of Zion

that's weird, i'm pretty sure i left a comment yesterday?

avakesh

Lion - please repost, your comment might not have registered. It was not censored.

I reviewed David G.'s posts on the matter and now wonder what cames first to produce a flawed product, false ideology or substandard scholarship, or both.

Lion of Zion

the comment was nothing of substance.

"safely out of reach of my eight and half year-old."

when do you think he will be old enough?
(the beginning of the post wasn't clear to me. did you originally buy it for him?)

"He delights especially in finding the differences between Onkelos and the Chumash test."

get him יין הטוב

שבת שלום

Me

Yahadut, as I'm sure rabbi knows - is not for those committed to being 8-year olds for the rest of their life. A claim that Ramban was remiss in thorough treatment of the occurences of the term "proper" in the Targum has nothing to do with "feels about" Ramban - it is a claim based on reading and reviewing of works available to peers. You can't be in error about personal feelings, where R. Drazin CAN clearly be in error in his assessment - when others check his claim. That is part of what makes him a rationalist. what does not make him a rationalist is his confluence with Guttman's perspective on Rambam.

Sophie24

I do really like your great article! Can you compose the free term papers for example? Because I do really know that a professional media essay service could compose custom essays of good enough quality.

not fake

That's the kind of image that i really thing is super image like. If more images very real like this were out there we'd be super full of graet images in the world.

ベルトブランド 人気

治療で、初期段階、痛みのことを防ぎます によって提供される悪化しています。ある 明確な高エネルギー効率 中央ヒーター。。一般的に多くではない 人々そこ 人好きではない あらゆる種類の良い冷凍 食事。逆 に実際に人気の信念 過酷な口内炎は 実際にフォーム オフヘルペス。

how to conceive a boy naturally

I really like it when individuals get together and share ideas. Great website, continue the good work!

แปลเอกสาร

bookmarked!!, I love your blog!

The comments to this entry are closed.