« New Yorker on Jewish denominations | Main | An exchange about Ashrei »

June 01, 2009

Comments

Yehonasan

Re: Reform ideology: Have you read R. Antelman's polemic work "To Eliminate the Opiate"? He submits that the founding of Reform was an Illuminati scheme to overthrow Judaism and the old world order. He is given to invective and hyperbole but if even only a small percentage of his claims are true, it is on the one hand quite dismaying, but on the other hand helps explain so much.

osoavakesh

I did not and thank you for pointing me to that. Professor Scholem did claim that Sabbateans were behind Haskala and Reform. His speculations about possible influences between Sabbatean and Reform Judaism in Hungary were criticized by Jacob Katz for lack of historical evidence. I understand that some more recent research based on archival research confirms that many of the founding Reform families in Prague were from Sabbatean families.

Yehonasan

Yes, R. Antelman also cites those sources. He also claims, though, that the Sabbatean/Frankist cults themselves were developed by the Illuminati as part of their plot, as was the communist movement. Maybe he is overreaching. However, the links between these various utopian subversive movements were interesting. For example, Abraham Geiger, a founder of Reform, had his salary and the costs of running the first Reform seminary in Breslau paid for by the Bund, a political party which later became known as the International Communist Party. Geiger's brother-in-law was Heinrich Oppenheim, one of the leaders of the failed Communist revolution in Germany in 1848.

steve mcqueen

If your reading is correct it is not a good reflection of our community that the only way a serious talmid hacham can make statements on issues of public concern is through the medium of childrens literatue!

S.

>"[Pinchos Lipschutz's] concern for a fellow Jew he was about to attack was touching."

I don't know about you, but this sounds like sarcasm designed not to sound sarcastic. I know R. Reinman goes on to condemn others who he feels are asid litein es ha-din, but I can't help the feeling that he was not quite so touched by Lipschutz heads-up that he was going to publish an "attack" on him.

Natan Slifkin

"Although R. Reinman does not cite him, Immanuel's opinion is, in fact, the view of Maharshal"

Also Chassam Sofer (in his chiddushim to Maseches Niddah p. 18a) concerning a discussion by the Rishonim about an aspect of human anatomy. He writes that “after investigations in books and from scholars in the field of anatomy, it is impossible for us to deny that the reality is not in accordance with the explanation of Rashi and Tosafos and the illustration of Maharam Lublin, and we have nothing other than that which the Rambam wrote in his compendium… and therefore I have not bothered at all in explaining the words of Rashi and Tosafos in this topic, because it is impossible to sustain them according to the reality, and you – know this!”

reverse cell phone lookup and free

One shows a much older man gaining the trust of a young teenage girl. Best of all, reverse cell phone lookup are fast, easy, accurate and complete. Any directory willing to back up the information it furnishes in any report in such a manner is very likely going to be a good bet to work with.

nice article

Much learning earns you much trouble. The more you know, the more you hurt.

amazing site

Even the most reasonable kids want a little seeking after when it comes to cell phone use and I firmly consider that all responsible parents should create use of a reverse cell number lookup service from time to time. We needn't suffer this method any longer, thanks to reverse phone search directories. Consequently, you can get your needed information after just few mouse clicks as a reverse phone detective.

jurassic-park-builder-cheats-hack-tool

Jurassic Park Builder Cheats What is Jurassic Park Builder You could have observed numerous e-book, video with regards to Jurassic Park at any place. Now there is a change to produce a dinosaur wonderland inside not too long ago released on-line myspace video game: Jurassic Park Builder. This is the cost-free online game to be able to play in PERSONAL COMPUTER, Notebook computer, apple iphone and apple ipad activity provides you with to the exotic Isla Nublar, where request you to build the greatest topic recreation area. Transforming dinosaurs, adding designs as well as security systems to create Jurassic Park the actual coolest put on Planet. This particular online game use a million participants. What exactly is Jurassic Park Builder Cheats Whenever you subscribe to this specific activity, it's possible at some time you obtain some sort of trouble using your harmony, Brucks, beef, coins… really feel uninteresting. This Cheats device permit you to get supreme all source ingame, enable you to feel at ease inside experience throughout Jurassic Park Builder online game. Jurassic Park Builder Cheats

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)