« Is it a quarter to or one minute to Maschiach? | Main | Tisha B'Av message from Hakhel »

August 11, 2008

Comments

Mechael

What about Midrashim or Chazal that contradict each other in factual historical senses like: Which species was eaten in Gan Eden? How was the Shofar blown? The exact shape of the Menorah? Not all of these are halachic related Chazal's, but how do we reconcile them??

Also, I don't see any contradction; the first Medrash does not say Moseh said the pasuk, but rather that he "decreed" it should be said....
Thanks. HB

avakesh

I suggest looking into this post where I have taken this question up:

http://www.avakesh.com/2007/10/an-approach-to-.html

The comments to this entry are closed.