Hadran: Peah

A story: R Chamma bar Chanina and  R. Yoshian were walking by the synagogues of Lod. Said R. R. Cham bar Chanina to R. Yoshiah: "How much money our fathers sunk in here!". He said to him: "How many souls our fathers sunk in here! Were there not people who would toil in Torah (and had no means to do so)?

This passage is repeated in Shekalim, end of Ch. 5. There the Yerushalmi adds:

R. Avun made gates for the "big" study hall. R. Mona came to him and R Avun told him, "see what I made". He responded: "And he (Israel) forgot the One who made him and built palaces (for Baal). Are there not people who would study Torah?"

Form standpoint of halacha, this passages serves as the basis for the law that moneys which were pledged synagogue building can be diverted to sustain Torah study (YO'D 249). However, it also teaches us a valuable perspective.

What it says to us is that people are more important than buildings.

I recall that many years ago I was conversing with a certain Rosh Yeshiva who was building an imposing addition to his yeshiva campus. Within the conversation he noted that nowadays the success of a mosad is judged by its building - the larger and more imposing the structure, the more successful the institution is thought to be. This threw me; fortunately, days later I spoke to another Rosh Yeshiva who bitterly bemoaned the time that fundraising for a new building was cosing him. He thought that I was fortunate in being able to have time, at that time,  to teach and write whereas he was forced to spend precious time on building valueless structures. This restored my soul, for the first Rosh Yeshiva was mistaken whereas this Torah leader understood Torah priorities better.

What this Yerushalmi passage teaches us is that no structure is forever, that every decision to devote resources to buildings takes away resources from people and that people are more important that buildings.

When R. Berel Wein was building his shul in Monsey an issue arose regarding selection of wood for building. The options were a less expensive  material that would last 45-50 years or a more expensive wood type that would last 90 years. The choice was for the former after R. Wein closed the discussion with the observation that he knows of few Jewish communities in recent history that lasted 90 years.

What the Yerushalmi ultimately teaches us is that in the eternal perspective of Spirit, the imposing, solid, material structures are evanescent and temporarily but the people remain forever.

For Succos, I add the following thought, heard in the name of Maharal ( I don't know where). He points out that we ask on Succos that Hashem will rebuild for us the fallen sukkah of David. Here the Beis Hamikdash is referred to as sukkah and not as bais (house). The reason for that is that a sukkah, even if fallen, is never destroyed. As a temporary structure, it can fall and still remain a sukkah, requiring only too be put up to functions. Not so a house. When a house falls down it ceases to be a house and cannot be rebuilt except as another house.

So also we must remember that the most enduring structure in the world is the temporary one and the best place in which to build a Temple is within the hearts of men...

(The very last passage of Peah is a restatement of the mishna and is probably brought there solely to end on a good note)

Hadran alach Peah...

 

Comments

[www.theeagleblog.com]

それ故にどのように彼らに適している用としてすべての種類関わって環境。ただし、良いことはする必要はありません有名になるにで素晴らしいそれらに関連付けられている。

[エアジョーダン]

ときあなた購入この靴に加え快適さ、することができますが表示されますすばらしい。彼ら提供様々 なにとしてサイズ高色として。

[イザベルマラン スニーカー]

。オンライン、ヨルダン20 のようないくつかのこともいるされて押し上げについて5000 元。数百万の世界の人々深さバスケット ボールので趣味あるいは専門的。

[エルメス]

それ、デザイナー ブランドの洋服、貴重な石リング、靴、自家製ジュエリーまたは新鮮なデザイナー ハンドバッグ。ことができます取得あなたのハンドバッグ評決で、非常に割引。毛皮を愛撫場合それは感じている絹のような滑らかなとソフトをタッチ、あなたはいた本当対処。重要なバッグは最も効果的なのバディ女性。

[エアジョーダン4]

They offer a variety attached to sizes as fine as colors. Information technology reputation rests for four pillars quality, price, delivery, so customization. Falling a hardly any inches short within six feet, In order to play the point guard position. For the money, this is a complete powerhouse of a mobile.

[グッチ メンズ バッグ]

これらは我々 のブランド実質的にする個人所有置くとを介して。これらの袋にすることができます発見される多くのショップ町の周りと、サイバー スペース。

[靴]

。今私場合疑問ことより多くを得る十分なから結果バックアップオフまたは再編？いくつか身に着けているこの特定getup はうまくいけば全然ない真の青いヒッピー。

[オークリー モンスダートッグ]

これによりメイン生徒を制限と大幅により手頃な価格コントラスト。可能性があります探索お得な本当上のバージョンオークション サイト。ファッションアクセサリーは多くの場合もを利用したを一緒に作成ユニークなとして渡って来る。

[work from home]

It's a shame you don't have a donate button! I'd without a doubt donate to this brilliant blog! I suppose for now i'll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to brand new updates and will talk about this blog with my Facebook group. Chat soon! http://wiki.clubginkgo.fr/index.php?title=Internet_Money_Path_Work_for_yourself